Basis Technology Corp. v. Amazon.com, Inc.

Basis Technology Corp. v. Amazon.com, Inc.

Basis Technology Corp. v. Amazon.Com, Inc., No. 06-P-1048, Appeals Ct. MA, 2008: Plaintiff successfully argued that an enforceable settlement had been reached via e-mail exchanges that were read for the record in court.


Issue: The enforceability of a disputed mid-trial settlement agreement

Case Details

  • Plaintiff sued Amazon and parties entered into a settlement agreement:
    • Important to note: parties came to agreement via e-mail exchanges and read the agreement for the record in court; court ordered parties to formalize agreement to be filed with court within 30 days, and parties ended up disagreeing on the terms and were unable to formalize for filing.
  • Plaintiff moved to enforce agreement and Amazon opposed.
  • Court ruled the e-mail settlement terms to be a valid and binding agreement. She entered judgment in favor of Basis for specific enforcement of the settlement terms. The judge deleted one term and made minor changes to others.
  • Amazon appealed enforcement of agreement.

Plaintiff’s Argument

  • Plaintiff and Amazon had a contract where Plaintiff was to provide certain limited services to Amazon, and Amazon held a certain amount of Plaintiff’s stock which was subject to the protection of antidilution.
  • Plaintiff sued Amazon for breach of fiduciary duty, quantum meruit, and violations for nonpayment for “out of scope” work.
  • Plaintiff argued agreement via email exchanges and read in open court was enforceable against Amazon.

Amazon’s Argument

Appealed enforcement of settlement upon two grounds:

  1. The e-mail exchanges did not create a complete and unambiguous agreement; and
  2. Amazon had not intended to be bound by the e-mail terms at the time of their exchange.
Basis Technology Corp. v. Amazon.com, Inc.

Summary and Conclusion

Court upheld that e-mail constituted a sufficiently complete and unambiguous settlement, and that both parties intended to be bound by that communication of settlement terms.

Latest Posts

CJ Rosenbaum Client Champion 2019

Contact Amazon Sellers Lawyer

SUBMIT A CASE

Email: CJ@AmazonSellersLawyer.com

Phone: 1-877-9-Seller

136 E. Park Avenue Long Beach, NY 11561

Attorney Advertising

The information provided on this website is not intended to be legal advice and does not create an attorney/client relationship. Internet subscribers are advised not to take any action based upon the material in this website without first consulting C.J. Rosenbaum or other legal counsel. We are not responsible for the accuracy of any information contained on any sites linked to ours. This website may be considered lawyer advertising by the State of New York.

Amazon Sellers Lawyer
Long Beach, NY 11561
Phone: 1-877-9-Seller